Integrated LED or GU10: which downlight should you choose?

An integrated LED downlight has its LEDs built in, so it can be slimmer and is often sealed, but the whole fitting is replaced when it fails. A GU10 downlight takes a mains bulb you can change yourself and needs more depth. Choose integrated for shallow ceilings, bathrooms and low glare, and GU10 for flexibility.

Key points

  • Integrated LED downlights have no bulb to change. When one fails, an electrician replaces the fitting.
  • GU10 downlights take a 230 V bulb you can swap yourself.
  • GU10 fittings used to be deeper, but our fire-rated GU10 downlight needs only 39 mm above the ceiling.
  • Both come in fire-rated versions. Sealed IP65 versions are easier to find in integrated designs.
  • Keep one type and one model on each switch or dimmer so the lights match.

The basic difference

An integrated LED downlight has its LEDs built into the fitting. A small electronic driver converts mains power for the LEDs, and the light, optics and heatsink are designed as one unit. There is no bulb to change.

A GU10 downlight is a housing with a lampholder. You push a GU10 bulb into it and twist to lock it in place. GU10 bulbs run directly on mains voltage (230 V), and any electronics sit inside the bulb itself, so there is no separate transformer or driver in the ceiling. When a bulb fails, you switch the light off, let it cool and fit a new one.

Both are good choices. The right one depends on your ceiling depth, the room, how you feel about changing bulbs and who will look after the lights in future.

Side-by-side comparison

Feature Integrated LED GU10
Upfront cost One price for a complete light, with nothing else to buy The fitting plus a bulb for each. Cheaper bulbs keep the cost down; better bulbs cost more
When the light fails The whole fitting is replaced by an electrician You swap the bulb yourself
Depth above the ceiling Slim. Most of ours need 35–60 mm Often deeper, to fit the bulb. Ours need 39–83 mm, depending on the model
Heat A heatsink designed for that LED draws heat away LED bulbs run far cooler than halogen, but must shed heat from a small body. Check the bulb suits enclosed fittings
Dimming Dimmable if stated. The driver and dimmer must be compatible Depends on the bulb. Every bulb on a dimmer must be dimmable, ideally all the same model
Looks Often slimmer, with low-glare options. Every light matches The bulb face is visible. Mixed bulbs can differ in colour and brightness
Fire-rated options Widely available, including slim, insulation-coverable designs Available in fire-rated housings. Ours is rated to 90 min
Lifespan (L70) Stated for the whole fitting. When output fades, the fitting is replaced Stated for each bulb. Bulbs are replaced as they fade and the housing stays
Colour choice Fixed, or switchable on the fitting Change it at any time by changing the bulbs
Water resistance Sealed shower-safe (IP65) versions are common Sealed housings exist, but many are indoor-only (IP20), including ours

A note on lifespan. LED life is usually given as an L70 figure, the number of hours until light output falls to 70% of new. LEDs tend to fade gradually, so the figure marks the point where you may notice the drop. Heat, the driver and the installation all affect real life, so treat hours as a way to compare lights rather than a promise of years.

Who integrated LED suits

Integrated downlights suit most new installations and renovations. They are a strong choice if any of these apply to you.

  • Shallow ceilings. Joists close to the plasterboard, pipes or a floor above can leave little room. Slim integrated fittings need far less depth than a GU10 housing.
  • Wet or steamy rooms. Factory-sealed shower-safe (IP65) versions suit bathrooms and busy kitchens.
  • Lights under a loft. Many integrated lights are insulation-coverable (IC), so loft insulation can go back over them. Check the insulation rating on the product page.
  • Comfort and a clean look. Deep low-glare optics and slim bezels are easier to find in integrated designs, and every light in the room matches.
  • No bulbs to buy. You never need to stock spares or climb a ladder to change a bulb.

The trade-off is replacement. When an integrated light reaches the end of its life, or its driver fails, an electrician has to replace the fitting or the driver. Keep a note of the model and its cut-out size so a future replacement fits the same hole.

Who GU10 suits

GU10 downlights make sense in a few situations.

  • You already have GU10 fittings. If your existing fittings are in good condition and take mains GU10 bulbs, swapping halogen bulbs for LED ones is often the simplest upgrade, though an old dimmer may need replacing.
  • You like to change things. You can change colour temperature, beam angle or brightness later by changing bulbs.
  • You’d rather change a bulb than call an electrician. A failed bulb is a quick swap.
  • You have plenty of depth. GU10 housings need more space above the ceiling, so they suit ceilings under a loft or with a generous void.

Be careful not to confuse GU10 with MR16. MR16 bulbs look similar but usually run at 12 V from a transformer. Swapping them for LED needs a compatible LED driver or rewiring, and an electrician should do it. Our halogen replacement guide explains how to tell which you have.

For landlords

Landlords weigh this choice differently, because every failed light can mean a call from a tenant. GU10 fittings let tenants replace bulbs themselves, and bulbs are easy to keep in stock. The risk is that tenants fit whatever bulb they find, including non-dimmable ones on a dimmer, which can flicker, or bulbs in a different colour.

Integrated fittings avoid bulb changes altogether, so there is less to go wrong day to day. When one does fail, you need an electrician and a replacement that fits the same hole. It’s worth buying a spare or two of the same model at the time. If a matching fitting is no longer available later, an adapter plate can help a smaller light fit an existing hole.

Whichever you choose, use fire-rated and, where needed, acoustic-rated fittings in ceilings between flats, and keep your installation certificates. Landlords also have their own electrical safety duties, including periodic inspection, and your electrician can advise on what applies to your property.

Bathrooms

Bathrooms favour integrated fittings. Directly over a bath or shower, up to 2.25 m from the floor, is Zone 1, where BS 7671 requires at least splash-resistant (IPX4) lights. We recommend water-jet-resistant (IP65) lights over a shower. Integrated IP65 downlights are sealed at the factory and never need opening.

A GU10 fitting can be used in a bathroom if its housing has the right IP rating for the zone. Each bulb change means opening the seal, so it has to be refitted carefully every time. Our fire-rated GU10 downlights are IP65 from below, so they can go over a bath or shower; the tilting version is IP20, so keep that outside the bathroom zones. Every bathroom circuit needs RCD protection, whichever type you choose.

Our bathroom zones guide explains where each zone ends, and our shower-safe IP65 downlights are grouped together.

Mixing both types

You can use integrated lights in some rooms and GU10 in others. A common approach is sealed integrated lights in the bathroom and kitchen, and GU10 in rooms where you might want to change the mood later.

Within one room, or on one switch or dimmer, stick to one type and one model. Different fittings dim differently and their colours rarely match exactly, so a mixed row can look patchy. Dimmers also have minimum and maximum loads, and mixing different lights makes it harder to stay within them. Our dimmer and flicker guide explains what to check.

If you are replacing only some of the lights in a room, consider replacing the whole group so they match.

Three to compare

These three show the range. Our fire-rated GU10 downlight takes any GU10 bulb, so you choose the colour and brightness; we sell dimmable bulbs to go with it. Our magnetic-bezel downlight is integrated, needs 50 mm, is shower-safe (IP65) and switches between 2700, 3000, 4000 and 6000 K. Our trimless GU10 downlight plasters in flush for a clean, rimless ceiling.

Browse our GU10 downlights or all fire-rated downlights, or answer a few questions and we’ll show what fits your ceiling.

Questions

Are integrated LED downlights better than GU10?

Neither is better in every case. Integrated downlights are slimmer, often sealed and usually better at controlling glare, but the whole fitting is replaced when it fails. GU10 downlights need more depth and let you change bulbs, colour and beam whenever you like. Choose by your ceiling depth, the room and who will look after the lights.

What happens when an integrated LED downlight fails?

The LEDs can’t be removed, so an electrician replaces the fitting. Sometimes the driver fails rather than the LEDs, and on some fittings the electrician can replace just the driver. Keep a note of the model and cut-out size so a replacement fits the same hole. If the holes no longer match, an adapter plate can cover the gap.

Can I change a GU10 bulb myself?

Yes. Switch the light off and let the bulb cool, then push it in gently, twist it anticlockwise and pull it out. Fit the new bulb the same way in reverse. Use a dimmable bulb if the light is on a dimmer, and match the colour temperature of the other bulbs in the room. Our fire-rated GU10 downlights come without a bulb, and we sell dimmable GU10 bulbs in 2700, 3000 and 4000 K to go with them.

Do GU10 downlights need more depth than integrated LED?

Often, because the housing has to fit the bulb and its lampholder. It depends on the design: our fire-rated GU10 downlight needs only 39 mm, the version with an insulation guard needs 83 mm, and most of our integrated downlights need 35–60 mm. Measure with the lighting circuit switched off at the consumer unit before you choose. Our measuring guide shows how.

Are integrated LED downlights fire-rated?

Many are, but check the product page for a rating of 30, 60 or 90 min. The rating relates to the ceiling construction the light was tested in. Fire-rated GU10 housings are also available. Where a fire-rated light is needed and you choose one that isn’t, a fire hood can be fitted above it. See our fire-rated downlights guide.

How long do integrated LED downlights last?

LED life is usually given as an L70 figure, the number of hours until output falls to 70% of new. The light doesn’t stop at that point. It has faded enough that you may notice. Heat, the driver and the installation all affect real life, so use L70 hours to compare lights. Our L70 definition explains more.

Should landlords choose integrated or GU10 downlights?

It depends on how you handle repairs. GU10 lets tenants replace bulbs, which saves call-outs, but mismatched or non-dimmable bulbs can cause flicker. Integrated lights avoid bulb changes, but a failure needs an electrician and a matching fitting, so it’s worth keeping a spare or two. For ceilings between flats, choose fire-rated downlights.

The Downlight Co. · All downlights · Guides · Help · Basket